Select a pillar to view its checks. Check IDs link to the complete Standard.
P1 — Verified Credentials & Compliance · 20 points
| ID | Pillar | Points | Check | Full / Partial rule | Typical IV source |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| C1 | P1 | 3 | Legal entity active and matches trading name | Full: entity active in state registry, name/DBA matches. Partial: active but name mismatch unexplained. | State Secretary of State business search |
| C2 | P1 | 6 | Capability-required licenses / registrations current | Full: every required item for the capability is current. Partial: required items current but one is pending renewal (<60 days). N/A for capabilities with none. | FDA WDD/3PL database, state boards, PHMSA search, SQFI/BRCGS directories |
| C3 | P1 | 4 | Quality / safety management certification | Full: accredited certificate in scope for the facility (ISO 9001, GFSI scheme, ISO 13485, GDP audit). Partial: documented internal QMS (SOPs, CAPA log) without certification. | IAF CertSearch, SQFI/BRCGS directories, certification body letter |
| C4 | P1 | 2 | Security / trade compliance program | Full: C-TPAT certified, TAPA FSR, or CBP-bonded/FTZ status. Partial: written security program (access control, CCTV retention, background checks). | CBP SVI screenshot shared live, TAPA register, CBP/FTZ records |
| C5 | P1 | 3 | Insurance: warehouse legal liability + general liability | Full: current COI naming both coverages with stated limits. Partial: one coverage only or limits not stated. | COI confirmed with broker by email/phone |
| C6 | P1 | 2 | Clean regulatory record | Full: no OSHA serious/willful citations (36 mo), no FDA warning letters or PHMSA penalties (24 mo) for the facility. Partial: one resolved item with documented corrective action. | OSHA establishment search, FDA warning letters, PHMSA enforcement data |
Rendered from standard.json; where they differ, the JSON governs.
P2 — Operational Proof · 25 points
| ID | Pillar | Points | Check | Full / Partial rule | Typical IV source |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| O1 | P2 | 6 | Order accuracy | Full: ≥99.5% trailing 6+ months. Partial: ≥99.0%. | Live WMS report observed by grader (timestamped capture) |
| O2 | P2 | 6 | On-time ship / SLA adherence | Full: ≥98% shipped within agreed cutoff. Partial: ≥95%. | Live WMS/OMS report observed by grader |
| O3 | P2 | 4 | Dock-to-stock time | Full: median ≤24 business hours receipt-to-available. Partial: ≤48 hours. | Live WMS report observed by grader |
| O4 | P2 | 4 | Inventory accuracy | Full: cycle-count accuracy ≥99.5%. Partial: ≥99.0%. | Live WMS report or cycle-count log observed by grader |
| O5 | P2 | 3 | Measurement maturity | Full: monthly KPI reports from the WMS for ≥12 months with written metric definitions. Partial: ≥6 months, or no written definitions. | KPI pack observed live |
| O6 | P2 | 2 | Capability-specific operational control | See capability table (e.g., temperature alarm logs, DG segregation, chargeback rate). | Capability-specific record observed live |
Rendered from standard.json; where they differ, the JSON governs.
P3 — Capability Fit · 20 points
| ID | Pillar | Points | Check | Full / Partial rule | Typical IV source |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| F1 | P3 | 4 | Facility verified | Full: address, square footage, dock doors and operating hours confirmed. Partial: address confirmed only. | Address in 2+ independent sources + imagery + live/virtual walkthrough |
| F2 | P3 | 5 | Capability infrastructure | Full: all infrastructure items in the capability table present. Partial: at least half present. | Walkthrough, equipment list with photos dated <12 mo |
| F3 | P3 | 4 | WMS and client visibility | Full: named WMS with client portal showing real-time inventory and orders. Partial: named WMS, reports by email only. | Live portal demo |
| F4 | P3 | 4 | Integrations for the capability's channels | Full: all integration items in the capability table. Partial: at least one. | Live demo or integration list in vendor marketplace |
| F5 | P3 | 3 | Demonstrated experience in this capability | Full: ≥2 years AND ≥10 active clients in the capability at this facility. Partial: ≥1 year OR ≥3 clients. | Reference calls, client list under NDA |
Rendered from standard.json; where they differ, the JSON governs.
P4 — Customer Evidence · 15 points
| ID | Pillar | Points | Check | Full / Partial rule | Typical IV source |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| E1 | P4 | 6 | Verified customer references | Full: 2+ current clients reached by grader with the standard script. Partial: 1 reference. | Grader call/email with reference (script in Appendix) |
| E2 | P4 | 3 | Case studies with named clients and outcomes | Full: 1+ case study naming the client with quantified results for this capability. Partial: named client, no numbers (or numbers, no name). | Client confirms case study |
| E3 | P4 | 3 | Third-party review signal | Full: ≥10 reviews on recognized platforms, average ≥4.3, no suspicious spikes. Partial: 5-9 reviews or average 4.0-4.29. | Grader views platform directly (counts as independently verified) |
| E4 | P4 | 3 | Client retention | Full: average client tenure ≥3 years or annual logo retention ≥85%. Partial: tenure 2-3 years or retention 70-84%. | Anonymized client tenure list confirmed by one reference |
Rendered from standard.json; where they differ, the JSON governs.
P5 — Business Stability · 10 points
| ID | Pillar | Points | Check | Full / Partial rule | Typical IV source |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| S1 | P5 | 3 | Years operating | Tiered: ≥10 years 1.0; 5-9 years 0.75; 2-4 years 0.5; <2 years 0. | State registry formation date / facility opening record |
| S2 | P5 | 2 | Continuity and redundancy | Full: written business-continuity plan (backup power, IT recovery) or a second facility able to absorb volume. Partial: one of the elements. | Plan reviewed live |
| S3 | P5 | 2 | Ownership and leadership transparency | Full: named leadership and ultimate owner/parent disclosed. Partial: leadership named only. | Registry, press releases, LinkedIn cross-check |
| S4 | P5 | 3 | Financial and legal flags | Full: no bankruptcy (5 yr), no material judgments/liens, no pattern of customer suits. Partial: one resolved item, explained. | Bankruptcy, court and lien searches |
Rendered from standard.json; where they differ, the JSON governs.
P6 — Transparency & Freshness · 10 points
| ID | Pillar | Points | Check | Full / Partial rule | Typical IV source |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| T1 | P6 | 3 | Pricing model transparency | Full: published or standard rate card covering receiving, storage, pick/pack, minimums and account fees. Partial: fee categories listed without rates. | Rate card on website (counts as independently verified when public) |
| T2 | P6 | 3 | Written SLAs with remedies | Full: standard contract has SLAs with credits or remedies. Partial: SLAs without remedies. | Contract template reviewed |
| T3 | P6 | 2 | Evidence recency | Full: ≥80% of evidence items dated within 12 months. Partial: 50-79%. | Computed by grading system |
| T4 | P6 | 2 | Responsiveness and data upkeep | Full: questionnaire answered within 15 business days and profile data current. Partial: answered late or partially. | Computed by grading system |
Rendered from standard.json; where they differ, the JSON governs.