Status: v1.0 draft for publication · Effective:
[EFFECTIVE DATE]· Published by:[LEGAL ENTITY NAME], which also operates 3PLGrade.com · Review: annually by the Advisory Council (§3.16) · License:[LICENSE - see Open decisions §15]The words must, must not and may are normative. Check IDs (C1…T4), point values, multipliers, bands, caps and red flags in this section are the official rules. Where any table on the website differs from
standard.json,standard.jsongoverns.
3.1 Purpose and principles Normative
The 3PL Grade tells a buyer, in one line, how well-evidenced a provider’s ability is to deliver a specific logistics capability at a specific facility.
| Principle | What it means in practice |
|---|---|
| Evidence over claims | Each check is weighted by how its evidence was obtained (§3.7). Marketing claims alone cannot earn a grade. |
| Capability and facility specific | A provider can be A in Ecommerce Fulfillment at one site and ungraded in Cold Chain at another. |
| Simple enough to apply consistently | 6 pillars, 29 checks, 3 answers per check (Full / Partial / None) and 4 evidence levels. A trained grader with AI assistance can grade one capability at one facility from a prepared evidence pack in about 60-90 minutes (planning estimate, to be confirmed in pilot). |
| No public shaming | Low or thin evidence shows as “Not graded - insufficient evidence”, never as D or F (§3.10). |
| Payment never buys points | §3.11. One sentence, used everywhere. |
| Dated and expiring | Every grade shows its month and year and expires after 12 months (§3.13). |
| Contestable | Providers see the grade before publication and can dispute it with fixed response times (§3.14). |
3.2 Definitions Normative
| Term | Definition |
|---|---|
| Provider | A company offering third-party warehousing, fulfillment or related logistics services to other businesses. |
| Facility | One physical site operated by the provider (or under its day-to-day operational control), identified by street address. |
| Capability | A service family defined in §3.4 (e.g., ECOM). |
| Grade record | The result of grading one provider x one facility x one capability under one Standard version. |
| Check | One of the 29 evidence questions in §3.6. |
| Achievement | How fully the check is met: Full = 1.0, Partial = 0.5, None = 0 (S1 uses tiers). |
| Evidence level | IV, DP, PC or NONE, with multipliers 1.0 / 0.75 / 0.4 / 0 (§3.7). |
| Applicable | A check that applies to the capability. Non-applicable checks are excluded and the pillar is re-scaled (§3.8). |
| Evidence coverage | Share of applicable points backed by IV or DP evidence (§3.9). |
| Grader / Reviewer | Trained staff who score a record / a second person who approves it. Neither may see the provider’s payment status (§3.11). |
3.3 Eligibility Normative
A grade record may be created when all of the following are true:
- The facility is in the United States (v1.0 scope).
- The provider has performed the capability at that facility for at least 6 months.
- The provider serves third-party clients (in-house distribution centers are out of scope).
- No red flag in §3.9.3 is active.
Providers do not have to apply or pay to be graded. 3PLGrade.com may open a record from public evidence; such records usually remain “Not graded - insufficient evidence” until the provider supplies documents or verification (see the worked example, §5.4).
3.4 Capabilities in v1.0 Normative
Eight capabilities launch in v1.0. Planned for later versions (not gradable in v1.0): Freight & Transportation Management, Bonded Warehousing & FTZ, Oversized & White-Glove, Cross-Border Fulfillment.
| Code | Capability | C2 requirements | O6 control | F2 infrastructure | F4 integrations |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| ECOM | Ecommerce & DTC Fulfillment | None (C2 = N/A) | Peak-season performance: on-time ship ≥97% during the most recent Nov-Dec peak, documented | Pack stations; daily pickups by ≥2 parcel carriers; same-day ship cutoff at or after 12:00 local; dimensional/weight capture | Native or certified connector to ≥1 storefront platform (e.g., Shopify, BigCommerce, WooCommerce, Adobe Commerce) and ≥1 marketplace |
| B2B | B2B & Retail Distribution | None (C2 = N/A) | Retailer compliance: chargebacks/deductions ≤1% of shipped invoice value over trailing 12 months, documented | Dock doors with scheduled LTL/TL appointments; pallet build/wrap; GS1-128 carton/pallet labeling | EDI 940/945/856 (or API equivalent) and experience with ≥1 retailer routing guide |
| FBA | Amazon FBA & Marketplace Prep | None (C2 = N/A) | Amazon inbound defects: prep/labeling non-compliance ≤1% of units over trailing 6 months, documented | FNSKU labeling; poly-bag/bubble wrap; case-pack and carton labeling; carton forwarding | Documented Amazon Seller Central / SP-API workflow; optional Walmart WFS prep |
| COLD | Cold Chain & Food-Grade — Regulated: verified credentials required | Facility holds a current GFSI-benchmarked certificate in a storage & distribution scope (e.g., SQF, BRCGS Storage & Distribution) AND FDA food facility registration (document accepted; FDA registration is not public) | Continuous temperature monitoring with alarms; excursion log reviewed with corrective actions; no unresolved excursion in 90 days | Temperature zones as offered (refrigerated 2-8 C and/or frozen ≤ -18 C); backup power; temperature mapping within 24 months; pest control program | Lot and expiry tracking with FEFO allocation in the WMS; temperature data visible to clients |
| HAZ | Hazmat & Dangerous Goods — Regulated: verified credentials required | PHMSA hazmat registration current where the provider's activities require it (grader records the basis) AND documented DOT hazmat training for handling staff (49 CFR 172.704) | DG segregation by hazard class verified; incident log shows no reportable incident in 24 months | Segregated/compatible storage; fire protection appropriate to stored classes; spill response kits; DG-trained shipping staff | WMS records UN number and hazard class; carrier DG accounts; shipping-paper generation |
| PHARMA | Pharma, Medical & Healthcare — Regulated: verified credentials required | For Rx drug 3PL services: facility appears in FDA's Wholesale Distributor & 3PL licensure reporting database AND holds required state license(s). For medical devices: FDA establishment registration where applicable | DSCSA-compliant chain of custody / product tracing; controlled-room-temperature monitoring; deviations and CAPA closed within 30 days | Temperature-mapped storage (e.g., 20-25 C controlled room temperature); quarantine and returns cage; secure high-value area; restricted access | Lot/serial tracking; EDI/ASN with trading partners; recall management workflow |
| RET | Returns & Reverse Logistics | None (C2 = N/A) | Returns processing: median ≤3 business days from receipt to disposition, documented | Dedicated inspection/grading area; refurbishment/repackaging; disposition channels (restock, liquidate, recycle, destroy with certificate) | Returns platform or RMA integration; client-visible disposition reporting |
| KIT | Kitting & Value-Added Services | None (C2 = N/A) | Kitting accuracy ≥99.5% with documented QC sampling over trailing 6 months | Dedicated assembly lines; shrink-wrap/bagging; labeling and printing equipment | Bill-of-materials / kit management in the WMS; work-order tracking visible to clients |
Rendered from standard.json; where they differ, the JSON governs.
3.5 Pillars and points Normative
| Pillar | Name | Points | Checks | What it answers |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| P1 | Verified Credentials & Compliance | 20 | C1 (3), C2 (6), C3 (4), C4 (2), C5 (3), C6 (2) | Is the provider legitimate, licensed, insured and compliant for this capability? |
| P2 | Operational Proof | 25 | O1 (6), O2 (6), O3 (4), O4 (4), O5 (3), O6 (2) | Can it prove it performs, with real KPI data? |
| P3 | Capability Fit | 20 | F1 (4), F2 (5), F3 (4), F4 (4), F5 (3) | Does this facility have what this capability needs? |
| P4 | Customer Evidence | 15 | E1 (6), E2 (3), E3 (3), E4 (3) | Do real customers confirm it? |
| P5 | Business Stability | 10 | S1 (3), S2 (2), S3 (2), S4 (3) | Will it still be there next year? |
| P6 | Transparency & Freshness | 10 | T1 (3), T2 (3), T3 (2), T4 (2) | Is it clear on price and terms, and is the evidence current? |
Rendered from standard.json; where they differ, the JSON governs.
3.6 Checks Normative
Each check has a maximum point value. Points earned = max points x achievement x evidence multiplier.
| ID | Pillar | Points | Check | Full / Partial rule | Typical IV source |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| C1 | P1 | 3 | Legal entity active and matches trading name | Full: entity active in state registry, name/DBA matches. Partial: active but name mismatch unexplained. | State Secretary of State business search |
| C2 | P1 | 6 | Capability-required licenses / registrations current | Full: every required item for the capability is current. Partial: required items current but one is pending renewal (<60 days). N/A for capabilities with none. | FDA WDD/3PL database, state boards, PHMSA search, SQFI/BRCGS directories |
| C3 | P1 | 4 | Quality / safety management certification | Full: accredited certificate in scope for the facility (ISO 9001, GFSI scheme, ISO 13485, GDP audit). Partial: documented internal QMS (SOPs, CAPA log) without certification. | IAF CertSearch, SQFI/BRCGS directories, certification body letter |
| C4 | P1 | 2 | Security / trade compliance program | Full: C-TPAT certified, TAPA FSR, or CBP-bonded/FTZ status. Partial: written security program (access control, CCTV retention, background checks). | CBP SVI screenshot shared live, TAPA register, CBP/FTZ records |
| C5 | P1 | 3 | Insurance: warehouse legal liability + general liability | Full: current COI naming both coverages with stated limits. Partial: one coverage only or limits not stated. | COI confirmed with broker by email/phone |
| C6 | P1 | 2 | Clean regulatory record | Full: no OSHA serious/willful citations (36 mo), no FDA warning letters or PHMSA penalties (24 mo) for the facility. Partial: one resolved item with documented corrective action. | OSHA establishment search, FDA warning letters, PHMSA enforcement data |
| O1 | P2 | 6 | Order accuracy | Full: ≥99.5% trailing 6+ months. Partial: ≥99.0%. | Live WMS report observed by grader (timestamped capture) |
| O2 | P2 | 6 | On-time ship / SLA adherence | Full: ≥98% shipped within agreed cutoff. Partial: ≥95%. | Live WMS/OMS report observed by grader |
| O3 | P2 | 4 | Dock-to-stock time | Full: median ≤24 business hours receipt-to-available. Partial: ≤48 hours. | Live WMS report observed by grader |
| O4 | P2 | 4 | Inventory accuracy | Full: cycle-count accuracy ≥99.5%. Partial: ≥99.0%. | Live WMS report or cycle-count log observed by grader |
| O5 | P2 | 3 | Measurement maturity | Full: monthly KPI reports from the WMS for ≥12 months with written metric definitions. Partial: ≥6 months, or no written definitions. | KPI pack observed live |
| O6 | P2 | 2 | Capability-specific operational control | See capability table (e.g., temperature alarm logs, DG segregation, chargeback rate). | Capability-specific record observed live |
| F1 | P3 | 4 | Facility verified | Full: address, square footage, dock doors and operating hours confirmed. Partial: address confirmed only. | Address in 2+ independent sources + imagery + live/virtual walkthrough |
| F2 | P3 | 5 | Capability infrastructure | Full: all infrastructure items in the capability table present. Partial: at least half present. | Walkthrough, equipment list with photos dated <12 mo |
| F3 | P3 | 4 | WMS and client visibility | Full: named WMS with client portal showing real-time inventory and orders. Partial: named WMS, reports by email only. | Live portal demo |
| F4 | P3 | 4 | Integrations for the capability's channels | Full: all integration items in the capability table. Partial: at least one. | Live demo or integration list in vendor marketplace |
| F5 | P3 | 3 | Demonstrated experience in this capability | Full: ≥2 years AND ≥10 active clients in the capability at this facility. Partial: ≥1 year OR ≥3 clients. | Reference calls, client list under NDA |
| E1 | P4 | 6 | Verified customer references | Full: 2+ current clients reached by grader with the standard script. Partial: 1 reference. | Grader call/email with reference (script in Appendix) |
| E2 | P4 | 3 | Case studies with named clients and outcomes | Full: 1+ case study naming the client with quantified results for this capability. Partial: named client, no numbers (or numbers, no name). | Client confirms case study |
| E3 | P4 | 3 | Third-party review signal | Full: ≥10 reviews on recognized platforms, average ≥4.3, no suspicious spikes. Partial: 5-9 reviews or average 4.0-4.29. | Grader views platform directly (counts as independently verified) |
| E4 | P4 | 3 | Client retention | Full: average client tenure ≥3 years or annual logo retention ≥85%. Partial: tenure 2-3 years or retention 70-84%. | Anonymized client tenure list confirmed by one reference |
| S1 | P5 | 3 | Years operating | Tiered: ≥10 years 1.0; 5-9 years 0.75; 2-4 years 0.5; <2 years 0. | State registry formation date / facility opening record |
| S2 | P5 | 2 | Continuity and redundancy | Full: written business-continuity plan (backup power, IT recovery) or a second facility able to absorb volume. Partial: one of the elements. | Plan reviewed live |
| S3 | P5 | 2 | Ownership and leadership transparency | Full: named leadership and ultimate owner/parent disclosed. Partial: leadership named only. | Registry, press releases, LinkedIn cross-check |
| S4 | P5 | 3 | Financial and legal flags | Full: no bankruptcy (5 yr), no material judgments/liens, no pattern of customer suits. Partial: one resolved item, explained. | Bankruptcy, court and lien searches |
| T1 | P6 | 3 | Pricing model transparency | Full: published or standard rate card covering receiving, storage, pick/pack, minimums and account fees. Partial: fee categories listed without rates. | Rate card on website (counts as independently verified when public) |
| T2 | P6 | 3 | Written SLAs with remedies | Full: standard contract has SLAs with credits or remedies. Partial: SLAs without remedies. | Contract template reviewed |
| T3 | P6 | 2 | Evidence recency | Full: ≥80% of evidence items dated within 12 months. Partial: 50-79%. | Computed by grading system |
| T4 | P6 | 2 | Responsiveness and data upkeep | Full: questionnaire answered within 15 business days and profile data current. Partial: answered late or partially. | Computed by grading system |
Rendered from standard.json; where they differ, the JSON governs.
3.7 Evidence levels Normative
| Code | Level | Multiplier | Definition |
|---|---|---|---|
| IV | Independently verified | 1.00 | The grader confirmed the fact directly at the source: issuing registry lookup; certificate confirmed with the issuer or in its public database; a live WMS/portal report observed on screen-share (timestamped capture saved); a reference call; a third-party review platform viewed directly; a public court/bankruptcy/OSHA/FDA record; a live or virtual facility walkthrough. |
| DP | Document provided | 0.75 | The provider submitted a document the grader reviewed for authenticity and relevance (certificate PDF, COI, exported KPI report, contract template, policy, equipment list with dated photos) but did not confirm at the source. |
| PC | Public claim | 0.40 | The fact is stated by the provider publicly (website, marketing, directory profile, press release) with no supporting document. |
| NONE | No evidence | 0.00 | Nothing found or provided. |
Rendered from standard.json; where they differ, the JSON governs.
Rules
- Record the evidence level for every applicable check, even when achievement is None.
- Multi-item checks (C2, F2, F4): achievement is based on the items present; the evidence level is the lowest level among the items relied on.
- Registry exception: where no public registry exists for a required item (currently FDA food facility registration under COLD, and DOT hazmat training records under HAZ), a reviewed document (DP) is treated as IV for that item only.
- Public facts viewed directly count as IV: a public rate card (T1), a third-party review platform (E3), and public court, OSHA, FDA or registry records are independently verified when the grader views them at the source.
- Evidence older than 24 months counts as NONE. Evidence 12-24 months old is allowed but lowers T3.
- Each evidence item stores: type, source, URL or file reference, date of the underlying fact, date checked, and checker ID.
- AI assistance may find sources, extract values and propose achievement and evidence levels with citations. A human grader must confirm every check. AI output alone is never evidence.
3.8 Calculation Normative
for each applicable check c:
earned(c) = max_points(c) x achievement(c) x multiplier(evidence_level(c))
for each pillar p:
applicable_max(p) = sum of max_points of applicable checks in p
pillar_score(p) = (sum of earned in p) / applicable_max(p) x pillar_points(p)
(a pillar with no applicable checks keeps its full points - not used in v1.0)
raw_score = sum of pillar_score(p) over the six pillars
score = round_half_up(raw_score) # integer 0-100
score = min(score, every cap that applies) # §3.9.2
status/band = §3.9 and §3.10
Store pillar scores to 2 decimals; publish only the integer score, the band and the pillar breakdown.
What the multipliers imply (design property): a provider whose evidence is all documents (DP) can reach at most about 76 (B), because only the system-computed checks T3 and T4 are IV by default. A and A+ require independent verification of the most important facts. A provider with only public claims typically scores 30-45 (Not graded).
3.9 Publication rules Normative
3.9.1 Minimum evidence coverage Normative
A grade (letter + number) may be published only if both:
- Evidence coverage is at least 50%, where coverage = (applicable max points of checks with evidence IV or DP) / (total applicable max points); and
- Every pillar has at least one applicable check with evidence at PC or better.
Otherwise the status is Not graded - insufficient evidence.
3.9.2 Caps Normative
| ID | Condition | Rule |
|---|---|---|
| CAP-1 | No independently verified operational metric | If none of O1-O4 has evidence level IV, the score is capped at 81 (B). |
| CAP-2 | No independently verified facility | If F1 is not IV, the score is capped at 87 (B+). A and A+ require a verified facility. |
| CAP-3 | No customer verification | If E1 is not IV with full achievement (2+ references), the score is capped at 94 (A). A+ requires verified customers. |
| CAP-4 | Regulated capability without verified credentials | For COLD, HAZ and PHARMA, if C2 is not at full achievement with IV evidence (see the exception in 3.7), the status is Not graded regardless of score. |
Rendered from standard.json; where they differ, the JSON governs.
Caps are applied after rounding. A record shows which caps applied (e.g., “Capped at B: no independently verified operational metric”).
3.9.3 Red-flag overrides Normative
| ID | Red flag | Effect |
|---|---|---|
| RF-1 | Required license or registration lapsed, suspended or revoked | Hold |
| RF-2 | Open regulatory enforcement at the facility: FDA warning letter (24 mo, unresolved), OSHA willful or repeat citation (36 mo), PHMSA civil penalty (24 mo, unresolved) | Hold |
| RF-3 | Bankruptcy filing, receivership or assignment for benefit of creditors (active or within 24 mo) | Hold |
| RF-4 | Facility closed, sold, or no longer operated by the provider | Withdrawn |
| RF-5 | Falsified, altered or misattributed evidence | Withdrawn + 24-month ineligibility |
| RF-6 | Two or more active lawsuits by customers alleging loss or non-performance, or one alleging fraud, filed within 24 months | Hold |
Rendered from standard.json; where they differ, the JSON governs.
- Hold: no grade is displayed; the record shows “Grade on hold - under review since [date]”. Review must finish within 30 days, ending in reinstatement, re-grade, or withdrawal.
- Withdrawn: the record and seal are removed; under RF-5 the provider is ineligible for 24 months.
- Graders must run the red-flag searches (registries, OSHA, FDA, PHMSA, bankruptcy, court) for every record and at least every 6 months during validity.
3.9.4 Statuses Normative
| Status | Shown publicly as |
|---|---|
| graded | Letter + number + capability + facility + "Graded by 3PLGrade · MON YYYY" |
| not_graded | Not graded - insufficient evidence |
| hold | Grade on hold - under review since [date] |
| under_appeal | Current grade stays visible with a note "Under appeal" (or "Not graded" if the appeal concerns the first publication) |
| expired | Grade expired [date] for 30 days, then removed |
| withdrawn | Not shown |
Rendered from standard.json; where they differ, the JSON governs.
3.10 Grade bands Normative
| Band | Score | Public display |
|---|---|---|
| A+ | 95-100 | Letter + number, e.g. "A+ · 100" |
| A | 88-94 | Letter + number, e.g. "A · 94" |
| B+ | 82-87 | Letter + number, e.g. "B+ · 87" |
| B | 75-81 | Letter + number, e.g. "B · 81" |
| C+ | 68-74 | Letter + number, e.g. "C+ · 74" |
| C | 60-67 | Letter + number, e.g. "C · 67" |
| Not graded | 0-59 | "Not graded - insufficient evidence" (no number shown publicly) |
Rendered from standard.json; where they differ, the JSON governs.
Why there is no D or F. Because the 3PL Grade weights evidence, a low score usually means “we could not verify enough”, not “this provider performs badly”. Publishing D or F would mislabel providers whose operations may be fine, invite disputes and legal risk, and discourage providers from participating. The full score is always shared privately with the provider, with a list of missing evidence.
3.11 Independence and payment policy Normative
The one sentence (use verbatim everywhere payment is mentioned):
“Payment can buy verification speed and profile services. It never buys points, grades, rankings, or a place on a shortlist.”
Supporting rules:
- Free standard verification: every eligible provider can have its evidence independently verified at no charge in the standard queue (target: within 60 business days of a complete evidence pack). Paid expedited verification changes only when verification happens, never the rules applied. (This is what keeps the policy true: IV evidence raises scores, so verification itself must not be pay-only.)
- Blind grading: graders and reviewers do not see whether a provider pays for anything. Sales staff cannot create, edit, or approve grade records.
- Same rules for all: paying and non-paying providers are graded with the same checks, multipliers, caps and timelines (except expedited queue position).
- Featured placements on 3PLGrade.com are paid, always labelled “Featured”, shown outside ranked lists, and never change a grade.
- Conflicts of interest: graders, reviewers and council members must disclose financial or employment ties to any provider and recuse from records involving it. Disclosures are kept on file; council disclosures are published.
- Audit trail: every change to a grade record is logged (who, when, what, why) and retained for at least 3 years.
3.12 Grading process and quality control Normative
| Step | Who | Output | Target time |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Open record | System / grader | Provider, facility, capability; eligibility confirmed | - |
| 2. Public sweep (AI-assisted) | Grader | Registry, OSHA/FDA/PHMSA, court and review searches with citations | 15-20 min |
| 3. Provider evidence pack | Provider | Questionnaire + documents (template on .com) | Provider-paced |
| 4. Verification session | Grader + provider | 30-45 min screen-share: WMS KPI reports, client portal demo, virtual walkthrough; reference contacts collected | 45 min |
| 5. Reference calls | Grader | Standard script (§3.17), 2+ references | 2 x 15 min |
| 6. Score | Grader | Checks, evidence levels, caps, red flags; draft record | 15 min |
| 7. Review | Reviewer | Approves 100% of A/A+ and all COLD/HAZ/PHARMA records; 10% random sample of others | 10 min |
| 8. Provider preview | Provider | Sees draft grade + missing-evidence list; 10 business days to respond | 10 business days |
| 9. Publish | System | Grade record JSON, seal, verification URL on .com | - |
Calibration: each month, 5 records are graded independently by two graders. A difference over 3 points on any record triggers rubric clarification in the next PATCH or MINOR release.
3.13 Validity and re-grading Normative
- A grade is valid for 12 months from the grade date shown on the seal.
- Re-grade triggers (any one starts a re-grade within 30 days): facility relocation or major expansion; change of ownership or control; change in a required license; a red flag; material credible complaint; provider request with new evidence (at most once per quarter); a MAJOR version change of the Standard (re-grade at the next renewal, no later than 12 months after the new version takes effect).
- A grade stays under the Standard version it was issued with until it is re-graded.
3.14 Disputes and appeals Normative
| Stage | Who can file | Window | Response SLA |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pre-publication response | Provider | 10 business days after preview | Grader replies within 5 business days |
| Dispute (published grade) | Provider | Within 30 days of publication or of a change | Acknowledged within 2 business days; decision within 15 business days |
| Appeal | Provider | Within 15 business days of the dispute decision | Decided within 30 days by a reviewer not involved in the original record; a summary is shared with the Advisory Council each quarter |
| Accuracy report | Anyone (buyers, public) | Any time | Acknowledged within 2 business days; triaged within 10 business days |
Disputes must cite a specific check ID and supply evidence. Disputes can change achievement or evidence levels only; they cannot change rules. Outcomes are recorded in the grade record’s history.
3.15 Seal and citation rules Normative
- Only grade records published by 3PLGrade.com under this Standard may use the 3PL Grade seal or the phrase “3PL Grade” for a specific provider.
- The seal must show letter, number, capability, “Graded by 3PLGrade · MON YYYY”, and link to the record’s verification URL (
https://www.3plgrade.com/verify/[GRADE_ID]- placeholder path on .com). - Providers must not display an expired, withdrawn or on-hold grade, or present a self-assessment estimate as a grade.
- Recommended citation: see §10.4.
3.16 Versioning, changelog and review Normative
| Version change | Examples | Effect on existing grades |
|---|---|---|
| MAJOR (2.0) | Pillar weights, check points, multipliers, bands, caps | Re-grade at next renewal (within 12 months) |
| MINOR (1.1) | New capability, new accepted evidence source, threshold clarification that does not move points | None; new records use the new version |
| PATCH (1.0.1) | Wording, typos, examples | None |
- Every version is published at a permanent URL (
/standard/v1-0,/standard/v1-1…) and never edited after publication except for PATCH notes. - The changelog records date, version, change, reason and whether council review occurred.
- Annual review: each Q4 the Advisory Council reviews the Standard. Proposed changes are published for a 30-day public comment period before adoption.
3.17 Appendix: reference call script (E1) Informative
Ask the reference (a current client using this capability at this facility for at least 6 months):
- Confirm you are a current client, which services you use, and since when.
- On a 1-5 scale, how accurate are your orders? Any recurring problems?
- How reliably do they meet the agreed ship cutoffs and SLAs?
- How do they handle problems (communication, credits, root-cause fixes)?
- Would you choose them again for this service? Why or why not?
Record date, reference role (not name in public output), answers and the grader. A reference that cannot confirm it is a current client does not count.
Worked example — fictional provider, full calculation
“Example Fulfillment Co.” - Reno, NV - Capability: ECOM (Ecommerce & DTC Fulfillment). This provider, its data and its sources are invented for illustration. Use this example unchanged in the website’s Standard page and as the reference unit test.
5.1 Check-by-check
| Check | Max | Achievement | Evidence | Points earned | Note |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| C1 | 3 | 1 | IV | 3 | Active in Nevada registry; DBA matches |
| C2 | 6 | N/A | - | - | Not applicable to ECOM (excluded from P1) |
| C3 | 4 | 0.5 | DP | 1.5 | Internal QMS binder (SOPs, CAPA log); no ISO certificate |
| C4 | 2 | 0 | NONE | 0 | No security program evidence |
| C5 | 3 | 1 | DP | 2.25 | COI with both coverages and limits; broker not yet contacted |
| C6 | 2 | 1 | IV | 2 | OSHA, FDA, PHMSA searches clean |
| O1 | 6 | 1 | IV | 6 | 99.7% (12 mo), WMS report observed on screen-share |
| O2 | 6 | 1 | DP | 4.5 | 98.6% from exported KPI pack |
| O3 | 4 | 0.5 | DP | 1.5 | Median 36 h from exported KPI pack |
| O4 | 4 | 1 | DP | 3 | 99.6% cycle-count accuracy, exported log |
| O5 | 3 | 1 | DP | 2.25 | 12 monthly KPI reports with definitions |
| O6 | 2 | 0.5 | PC | 0.4 | Website claims 'peak-ready'; peak data not provided |
| F1 | 4 | 1 | IV | 4 | Virtual walkthrough + 2 address sources + imagery |
| F2 | 5 | 1 | DP | 3.75 | Equipment list with dated photos |
| F3 | 4 | 1 | IV | 4 | Live client-portal demo |
| F4 | 4 | 1 | DP | 3 | Integration list (Shopify, Amazon) document |
| F5 | 3 | 1 | DP | 2.25 | Client count list under NDA (14 ECOM clients, 4 yrs) |
| E1 | 6 | 1 | IV | 6 | 2 reference calls completed |
| E2 | 3 | 0.5 | PC | 0.6 | Named client on website, no numbers |
| E3 | 3 | 1 | IV | 3 | Google Business Profile: 23 reviews, 4.5 avg |
| E4 | 3 | 1 | DP | 2.25 | Average tenure 3.4 years (anonymized list) |
| S1 | 3 | 0.75 | IV | 2.25 | Formed 2019 (7 years) per registry |
| S2 | 2 | 0.5 | DP | 0.75 | Backup generator; no written IT recovery plan |
| S3 | 2 | 1 | PC | 0.8 | Leadership and owner named on website only |
| S4 | 3 | 1 | IV | 3 | Bankruptcy/court/lien searches clean |
| T1 | 3 | 1 | DP | 2.25 | Standard rate card provided (not public) |
| T2 | 3 | 0.5 | DP | 1.125 | SLAs in contract, no credits |
| T3 | 2 | 1 | IV | 2 | 88% of evidence dated within 12 months |
| T4 | 2 | 1 | IV | 2 | Answered in 9 business days |
Rules from standard.json; inputs and illustrative notes from the supplied worked example.
5.2 Result
| Pillar | Applicable max | Earned | Pillar points | Pillar score = earned / applicable x points |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| P1 Verified Credentials & Compliance | 14 | 8.75 | 20 | 12.5 |
| P2 Operational Proof | 25 | 17.65 | 25 | 17.65 |
| P3 Capability Fit | 20 | 17 | 20 | 17 |
| P4 Customer Evidence | 15 | 11.85 | 15 | 11.85 |
| P5 Business Stability | 10 | 6.8 | 10 | 6.8 |
| P6 Transparency & Freshness | 10 | 7.375 | 10 | 7.375 |
| Total (raw) | 94 | 100 | 73.175 |
Rules from standard.json; inputs and illustrative notes from the supplied worked example.
- Raw score 73.175 -> rounded 73.
- Coverage: 85 of 94 applicable points backed by IV or DP = 90% (passes the 50% minimum); every pillar has evidence.
- Caps: CAP-1 not triggered (O1 is IV); CAP-2 not triggered (F1 is IV); CAP-3 not relevant below 95. No red flags.
- Result: 3PL Grade C+ · 73 · Ecommerce & DTC Fulfillment · Reno, NV · Graded by 3PLGrade · [MON YYYY] · Standard v1.0
5.3 How the same provider improves (scenarios)
| Scenario | What changes vs 5.1 | Score | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| A. As graded (5.1) | - | 73 | C+ |
| B. Quick wins | O2, O4, O5 observed live (IV); COI confirmed with broker (C5 IV); case study with numbers (E2 full, DP) | 79 | B |
| C. Fully verified | B plus: walkthrough confirms F2; live integration demo (F4); experience confirmed by references (F5, E4); public rate card (T1); ISO 9001 found in IAF CertSearch (C3); O3 median 20 h and O6 peak report observed; client-confirmed case study; SLA credits; written BCP | 95 | A+ |
| D. Public information only | Provider does not participate; only registries, searches, reviews and website claims | 33 | Not graded - insufficient evidence (coverage 21%) |
Rules from standard.json; inputs and illustrative notes from the supplied worked example.
Takeaway for site copy: better evidence, not better marketing, moves a grade. A and A+ are only reachable when the key facts are independently verified. Most providers who publish only marketing claims will show “Not graded - insufficient evidence”; the site must explain this neutrally (“not yet graded” is not a negative finding).