3.7 Evidence levels Normative
| Code | Level | Multiplier | Definition |
|---|---|---|---|
| IV | Independently verified | 1.00 | The grader confirmed the fact directly at the source: issuing registry lookup; certificate confirmed with the issuer or in its public database; a live WMS/portal report observed on screen-share (timestamped capture saved); a reference call; a third-party review platform viewed directly; a public court/bankruptcy/OSHA/FDA record; a live or virtual facility walkthrough. |
| DP | Document provided | 0.75 | The provider submitted a document the grader reviewed for authenticity and relevance (certificate PDF, COI, exported KPI report, contract template, policy, equipment list with dated photos) but did not confirm at the source. |
| PC | Public claim | 0.40 | The fact is stated by the provider publicly (website, marketing, directory profile, press release) with no supporting document. |
| NONE | No evidence | 0.00 | Nothing found or provided. |
Rendered from standard.json; where they differ, the JSON governs.
Rules
- Record the evidence level for every applicable check, even when achievement is None.
- Multi-item checks (C2, F2, F4): achievement is based on the items present; the evidence level is the lowest level among the items relied on.
- Registry exception: where no public registry exists for a required item (currently FDA food facility registration under COLD, and DOT hazmat training records under HAZ), a reviewed document (DP) is treated as IV for that item only.
- Public facts viewed directly count as IV: a public rate card (T1), a third-party review platform (E3), and public court, OSHA, FDA or registry records are independently verified when the grader views them at the source.
- Evidence older than 24 months counts as NONE. Evidence 12-24 months old is allowed but lowers T3.
- Each evidence item stores: type, source, URL or file reference, date of the underlying fact, date checked, and checker ID.
- AI assistance may find sources, extract values and propose achievement and evidence levels with citations. A human grader must confirm every check. AI output alone is never evidence.
Evidence definitions
IV
The grader confirmed the fact directly at the source: issuing registry lookup; certificate confirmed with the issuer or in its public database; a live WMS/portal report observed on screen-share (timestamped capture saved); a reference call; a third-party review platform viewed directly; a public court/bankruptcy/OSHA/FDA record; a live or virtual facility walkthrough.
DP
The provider submitted a document the grader reviewed for authenticity and relevance (certificate PDF, COI, exported KPI report, contract template, policy, equipment list with dated photos) but did not confirm at the source.
PC
The fact is stated by the provider publicly (website, marketing, directory profile, press release) with no supporting document.
NONE
Nothing found or provided.
What does not count as evidence
AI summaries, unverifiable screenshots and testimonials without a named client do not independently verify a check. AI output alone is never evidence.