3.9 Publication rules Normative
3.9.1 Minimum evidence coverage Normative
A grade (letter + number) may be published only if both:
- Evidence coverage is at least 50%, where coverage = (applicable max points of checks with evidence IV or DP) / (total applicable max points); and
- Every pillar has at least one applicable check with evidence at PC or better.
Otherwise the status is Not graded - insufficient evidence.
3.9.2 Caps Normative
| ID | Condition | Rule |
|---|---|---|
| CAP-1 | No independently verified operational metric | If none of O1-O4 has evidence level IV, the score is capped at 81 (B). |
| CAP-2 | No independently verified facility | If F1 is not IV, the score is capped at 87 (B+). A and A+ require a verified facility. |
| CAP-3 | No customer verification | If E1 is not IV with full achievement (2+ references), the score is capped at 94 (A). A+ requires verified customers. |
| CAP-4 | Regulated capability without verified credentials | For COLD, HAZ and PHARMA, if C2 is not at full achievement with IV evidence (see the exception in 3.7), the status is Not graded regardless of score. |
Rendered from standard.json; where they differ, the JSON governs.
Caps are applied after rounding. A record shows which caps applied (e.g., “Capped at B: no independently verified operational metric”).
3.9.3 Red-flag overrides Normative
| ID | Red flag | Effect |
|---|---|---|
| RF-1 | Required license or registration lapsed, suspended or revoked | Hold |
| RF-2 | Open regulatory enforcement at the facility: FDA warning letter (24 mo, unresolved), OSHA willful or repeat citation (36 mo), PHMSA civil penalty (24 mo, unresolved) | Hold |
| RF-3 | Bankruptcy filing, receivership or assignment for benefit of creditors (active or within 24 mo) | Hold |
| RF-4 | Facility closed, sold, or no longer operated by the provider | Withdrawn |
| RF-5 | Falsified, altered or misattributed evidence | Withdrawn + 24-month ineligibility |
| RF-6 | Two or more active lawsuits by customers alleging loss or non-performance, or one alleging fraud, filed within 24 months | Hold |
Rendered from standard.json; where they differ, the JSON governs.
- Hold: no grade is displayed; the record shows “Grade on hold - under review since [date]”. Review must finish within 30 days, ending in reinstatement, re-grade, or withdrawal.
- Withdrawn: the record and seal are removed; under RF-5 the provider is ineligible for 24 months.
- Graders must run the red-flag searches (registries, OSHA, FDA, PHMSA, bankruptcy, court) for every record and at least every 6 months during validity.
3.9.4 Statuses Normative
| Status | Shown publicly as |
|---|---|
| graded | Letter + number + capability + facility + "Graded by 3PLGrade · MON YYYY" |
| not_graded | Not graded - insufficient evidence |
| hold | Grade on hold - under review since [date] |
| under_appeal | Current grade stays visible with a note "Under appeal" (or "Not graded" if the appeal concerns the first publication) |
| expired | Grade expired [date] for 30 days, then removed |
| withdrawn | Not shown |
Rendered from standard.json; where they differ, the JSON governs.
3.10 Grade bands Normative
| Band | Score | Public display |
|---|---|---|
| A+ | 95-100 | Letter + number, e.g. "A+ · 100" |
| A | 88-94 | Letter + number, e.g. "A · 94" |
| B+ | 82-87 | Letter + number, e.g. "B+ · 87" |
| B | 75-81 | Letter + number, e.g. "B · 81" |
| C+ | 68-74 | Letter + number, e.g. "C+ · 74" |
| C | 60-67 | Letter + number, e.g. "C · 67" |
| Not graded | 0-59 | "Not graded - insufficient evidence" (no number shown publicly) |
Rendered from standard.json; where they differ, the JSON governs.
Why there is no D or F. Because the 3PL Grade weights evidence, a low score usually means “we could not verify enough”, not “this provider performs badly”. Publishing D or F would mislabel providers whose operations may be fine, invite disputes and legal risk, and discourage providers from participating. The full score is always shared privately with the provider, with a list of missing evidence.
Published-grade display examples
Example — fictional. These specimens explain the display only; they are not issued grades.
Other fictional displays: B+ · 86; B · 81. See Verification to learn how a real seal is checked.