An open standard published by [LEGAL ENTITY NAME] · Ownership disclosure3PLGS 1:2026 (current) · All editions
3PLGS 1:2026Edition 1 · Version 1.0
Status
Draft for publication
Published
[EFFECTIVE DATE]
Supersedes
None (first edition)
Next review
Q4 annually
This version
Stable version 1.0
Publisher
[LEGAL ENTITY NAME]

Grade Bands, Caps & Red Flags

3.9 Publication rules Normative

3.9.1 Minimum evidence coverage Normative

A grade (letter + number) may be published only if both:

  • Evidence coverage is at least 50%, where coverage = (applicable max points of checks with evidence IV or DP) / (total applicable max points); and
  • Every pillar has at least one applicable check with evidence at PC or better.

Otherwise the status is Not graded - insufficient evidence.

3.9.2 Caps Normative

Publication caps
IDConditionRule
CAP-1No independently verified operational metricIf none of O1-O4 has evidence level IV, the score is capped at 81 (B).
CAP-2No independently verified facilityIf F1 is not IV, the score is capped at 87 (B+). A and A+ require a verified facility.
CAP-3No customer verificationIf E1 is not IV with full achievement (2+ references), the score is capped at 94 (A). A+ requires verified customers.
CAP-4Regulated capability without verified credentialsFor COLD, HAZ and PHARMA, if C2 is not at full achievement with IV evidence (see the exception in 3.7), the status is Not graded regardless of score.

Rendered from standard.json; where they differ, the JSON governs.

Caps are applied after rounding. A record shows which caps applied (e.g., “Capped at B: no independently verified operational metric”).

3.9.3 Red-flag overrides Normative

Red-flag overrides
IDRed flagEffect
RF-1Required license or registration lapsed, suspended or revokedHold
RF-2Open regulatory enforcement at the facility: FDA warning letter (24 mo, unresolved), OSHA willful or repeat citation (36 mo), PHMSA civil penalty (24 mo, unresolved)Hold
RF-3Bankruptcy filing, receivership or assignment for benefit of creditors (active or within 24 mo)Hold
RF-4Facility closed, sold, or no longer operated by the providerWithdrawn
RF-5Falsified, altered or misattributed evidenceWithdrawn + 24-month ineligibility
RF-6Two or more active lawsuits by customers alleging loss or non-performance, or one alleging fraud, filed within 24 monthsHold

Rendered from standard.json; where they differ, the JSON governs.

  • Hold: no grade is displayed; the record shows “Grade on hold - under review since [date]”. Review must finish within 30 days, ending in reinstatement, re-grade, or withdrawal.
  • Withdrawn: the record and seal are removed; under RF-5 the provider is ineligible for 24 months.
  • Graders must run the red-flag searches (registries, OSHA, FDA, PHMSA, bankruptcy, court) for every record and at least every 6 months during validity.

3.9.4 Statuses Normative

Grade-record statuses
StatusShown publicly as
gradedLetter + number + capability + facility + "Graded by 3PLGrade · MON YYYY"
not_gradedNot graded - insufficient evidence
holdGrade on hold - under review since [date]
under_appealCurrent grade stays visible with a note "Under appeal" (or "Not graded" if the appeal concerns the first publication)
expiredGrade expired [date] for 30 days, then removed
withdrawnNot shown

Rendered from standard.json; where they differ, the JSON governs.

3.10 Grade bands Normative

Grade bands
BandScorePublic display
A+95-100Letter + number, e.g. "A+ · 100"
A88-94Letter + number, e.g. "A · 94"
B+82-87Letter + number, e.g. "B+ · 87"
B75-81Letter + number, e.g. "B · 81"
C+68-74Letter + number, e.g. "C+ · 74"
C60-67Letter + number, e.g. "C · 67"
Not graded0-59"Not graded - insufficient evidence" (no number shown publicly)

Rendered from standard.json; where they differ, the JSON governs.

Why there is no D or F. Because the 3PL Grade weights evidence, a low score usually means “we could not verify enough”, not “this provider performs badly”. Publishing D or F would mislabel providers whose operations may be fine, invite disputes and legal risk, and discourage providers from participating. The full score is always shared privately with the provider, with a list of missing evidence.

Published-grade display examples

Example — fictional. These specimens explain the display only; they are not issued grades.

Fictional A plus 97 grade display
Figure 1 — How a published grade is displayed. Fictional example, informative only.
Fictional A 92 grade display
Figure 2 — How a published grade is displayed. Fictional example, informative only.

Other fictional displays: B+ · 86; B · 81. See Verification to learn how a real seal is checked.